Friday’s Package Fail: Why This Tear-Notch Pouch Failed

I woke up this morning, fed the dog, got my wife off to her teaching job, and drove my 17-year-old daughter to school. Time for breakfast — some toast, coffee, and granola covered in yogurt. I had finished off a pouch of granola yesterday, so I grabbed a new one. Here’s where the fun began.
I located the tear notch and started tearing. The package ripped about 40% across and stopped. I switched to the other side of the notch and tore again — another 40% and it stopped. Now I had this:

After a few choice words I cannot repeat here, I grabbed the scissors to finish opening the package. Then I took a closer look at the offending material.

Upon closer inspection, the material did not delaminate. That is the usual culprit when interlaminar bond strength is too weak and the print web separates from the sealant layer. In this case, the film simply was not designed to support a reliable linear tear. As soon as the tear passed the side weld, it immediately veered upward at a ~45° angle.
Compounding the problem was the top seal: it was a classic ghost seal — it looked sealed, but in many areas the seal was nonexistent or extremely weak. A stronger, consistent top seal might have kept the tear propagating linearly along the bottom edge of the seal.
The foolproof solution is laser scoring between the notches. But if that is not available from your converter, you must fix the material and process issues. All these problems could have been prevented with some very basic quality tests at both the film converter and the packer.
Film Converters: This Starts with You
Whether you are supplying premade pouches or roll stock, you are responsible for selecting and validating a film that actually works with a tear notch. If the customer asks for a tear notch, you must supply film that will tear from that notch in a straight line.
Here are the key tests that should be run before any pouches are made or roll stock is shipped:
ASTM F904 – Standard Test Method for Comparison of Bond Strength or Ply Adhesion of Similar Laminates Made from Flexible Materials Ensures the layers are properly bonded. If interlaminar bond strength is weak, tear performance and seal integrity will fail regardless of other factors.
ASTM F2029 – Standard Practices for Making Laboratory Heatseals for Determination of Heat Sealability of Flexible Barrier Materials Used to generate a complete heat seal curve. This data tells the packer exactly what temperature, pressure, and dwell settings are needed for strong, consistent seals. This information should be provided on the Certificate of Analysis (COA).
ASTM D1938 – Tear-Propagation Resistance (Trouser Tear Test) Determines whether the film will propagate a straight, linear tear from the notch. You can (and should) modify this test by sealing only half the sample and placing the tear notch just inside the sealed edge to closely mimic actual pouch conditions.
Editor's Note: There are obviously a whole lot of QC tests that should be run prior to shipment. These tests are strictly related to the tear notch.
Fillers / Packers: You’re Not Off the Hook
Even with good incoming material, you must verify performance on the production floor:
ASTM F88 / F88M – Standard Test Method for Seal Strength of Flexible Barrier Materials After making side seals and top seals, are you testing them to confirm they meet the seal strength values on the COA? Ghost seals should never make it out the door.
Functional Tear Testing Are you opening finished packages as part of in-process or final QC — the same way a real customer would? If not, why not?
Act like a customer in their kitchen. If a package fails to open easily and cleanly, stop. Investigate the root cause. If you can’t fix it, call your converter immediately. Do not just pack, seal, and ship while hoping for the best.
Your end users are the ones dealing with the frustration — and they’re the ones posting photos and videos when it goes wrong.
Editor’s Note: I have reached out to the end user with this information and an offer to help them.

